Insider Threats: Identifying and Mitigating Risks from Within
When people think about cybersecurity threats, they picture outside hackers trying to break through digital defences. But some of the biggest risks can come from inside a company; we call these ‘insider threats’. These threats pose a unique and big problem for organizations because the people behind them have real access to systems and data, which makes them harder to detect. Insider threats can come from employees, contractors, or business partners who intentionally hurt the organisation or by accident.
In this article, we will explore what insider threats are, how to identify them, and practical strategies to mitigate these risks, using relatable examples to illustrate these points.
What is an Insider Threat?
An insider threat refers to the risk posed by individuals within an organization who misuse their access to data, systems, or confidential information. These individuals may act either with bad intentions or innocently, causing data breaches, financial loss, or reputational damage.
Types of Insider Threats:
- Malicious Insiders
This group comprises individuals who intentionally violate their access to harm the organization. Their reasons for doing so might be financial attraction or personal issues like revenge and espionage. They might act out of financial greed, also for revenge purposes, as well as selling such information to competitors or even nation-state actors. - Negligent Insiders
These are employees who unintentionally cause harm by failing to adhere to security protocols or by making human errors. Such negligence invariably leads to data leaks, security breaches, or exposure of sensitive information to external threats. - Compromised Insiders
These personnel have had their credentials stolen by external attackers, making them legitimate identities through which those attackers can gain internal work access. - Third-party/Partners
These are temporary employees who have access to company systems and can equally turn out to be insider threats, particularly if they haven’t been properly screened or trained on cybersecurity policies. - Privileged Insiders
Employees with elevated privileges, such as system administrators or database managers, have the potential to cause greater damage due to their extensive access to critical systems.
Why Insider Threats Are Hard to Detect
The primary challenge with insider threats is that abusers have legitimate access to the systems. This makes detection particularly difficult because their acts may not appear suspicious immediately. To identify these risks, a combination of behavioural analytics and human vigilance is necessary.
1. Insiders Know Security Protocols
Insiders, particularly IT staff, might know how security protocols work and how they can be evaded, thus making it difficult to detect malicious activity early.
2. Access Is Often Legitimate
Unlike external attackers, insiders never need to break into the systems since they are already within the organization. This complicates the differentiation between normal and malicious activities
As Eugene Kaspersky, a world-renowned cybersecurity expert, once said, “The hardest part of cybersecurity is dealing with insiders because they are trusted and their actions are often invisible.”
Practical Examples of Insider Threats
Example 1: The Disgruntled Employee
Scenario: In 2019, a former employee of Capital One was charged for accessing over 100 million customer accounts. This individual had left the company but still managed to exploit a misconfigured web application firewall to gain unauthorized access to sensitive information. When they lose their jobs or miss getting promotions; angry workers may decide to destroy systems, erase files, or damage information so that it can be a blow against their companies.
Lesson: Disgruntled employees can inflict much harm even after quitting the organization due to their technical expertise and access privileges.
Example 2: The Negligent Employee
Scenario: In a Nigerian financial institution, an employee mistakenly sent confidential customer data to an unauthorized external party. This occurred because the employee failed to check the recipient list in their email client, leading to a significant data breach.
Lesson: Simple mistakes like sending emails to the wrong recipient can lead to data exposure. Unintentional insider threats are common and can have severe consequences.
Example 3: Compromised Credentials
Scenario: An employee in a Lagos-based tech company fell victim to a phishing scam, unknowingly providing their login credentials to an attacker. The attacker then used the employee’s credentials to access the company’s database and steal proprietary information.
Lesson: Even the most security-conscious employees can fall victim to phishing scams, which is why compromised credentials are a significant insider threat.
How to Identify Insider Threats
Identifying insider threats is tricky, but there are several red flags to watch out for:
- Unusual Behavior
Employees accessing data they don’t typically need or using the system at odd hours can be a sign of an insider threat.
Example: An employee who suddenly begins accessing sensitive files outside of their usual role may be preparing to leak or misuse information. For instance, if an employee in HR suddenly starts downloading large amounts of customer data, this should raise a red flag.
2. Increased Data Transfers
Large data downloads or uploads can be indicative of data exfiltration. Monitoring data flow for anomalies is critical for catching these threats early.
Example: If an employee suddenly begins transferring large files to external USB drives or cloud storage services, this could signal a potential breach.
3. Violation of Security Policies
Repeatedly trying to bypass security measures or ignore protocols should raise alarms.
Example: An employee who consistently disables security features such as multi-factor authentication (MFA) may be intentionally weakening the system for future malicious activities.
4. Disgruntled Employees
Employees who are visibly unhappy or have a history of conflicts with the organization are more likely to become malicious insiders.
Example: A recently demoted employee might feel wronged and seek revenge by compromising the organization’s data.
Mitigating Insider Threats
Mitigating insider threats requires a comprehensive approach that combines technology, policy, and fostering a culture of security awareness. Now that we’ve identified some signs of insider threats, how can organizations mitigate these risks? Here are some practical strategies:
1. Implement Strong Access Controls
Limit access to sensitive data based on the employee’s role. Use the principle of least privilege, ensuring that employees only have access to the data they need to perform their jobs.
Example: A junior marketing employee should not have access to the financial records of the company. Implementing role-based access controls can prevent this.
2. Monitor Employee Behavior
Use tools that monitor unusual activity, such as excessive data downloads or logins during off-hours. Behavioural analytics can help detect anomalies that suggest an insider threat.
Example: If an employee who typically works from 9 a.m. to 5 p.m. suddenly logs into the system at midnight and downloads sensitive files, an alert should be triggered.
3. Conduct Regular Employee Training
Educate employees on security best practices, such as avoiding phishing scams, using strong passwords, and understanding company policies around sensitive data.
Example: A Nigerian tech startup implementing quarterly security training, reducing the number of phishing victims within the company by 50%.
4. Foster a Positive Work Environment
Disgruntled employees are more likely to become insider threats. Creating a supportive, open workplace culture can reduce the likelihood of an employee seeking revenge or selling data.
As Tony Hsieh, the late CEO of Zappos, said, “Your culture is your brand.” By investing in employee satisfaction, companies can mitigate insider threats.
5. Regularly Audit Access Logs
Regular audits of who is accessing what data and when can help detect potential insider threats. Ensure that all access to sensitive systems and data is logged and reviewed periodically.
Example: After regular audits, a Nigerian bank discovered an employee accessing confidential client information that was outside their job scope, enabling the company to take action before a data breach occurred.
6. Use Data Loss Prevention (DLP) Tools
DLP tools help prevent sensitive data from leaving the organization. These tools can detect and block unauthorized attempts to copy, send, or download critical data.
Example: If an employee tries to upload a sensitive financial document to their personal Google Drive, a DLP tool will automatically block the action and alert the security team.
7. Employee Exit Protocols
When employees leave the organization, it’s essential to immediately revoke their access to all systems and data to prevent retaliation or continued access after termination.
Example: After an employee in a Lagos-based tech company resigned, their access was not immediately revoked. They were later found to have logged in after their departure to download confidential project documents, exposing a lapse in exit protocols.
Conclusion
Insider threats represent one of the most challenging aspects of cybersecurity because they stem from individuals who already have legitimate access to confidential information. The best way to mitigate these threats is to create a culture of awareness, regularly monitor for unusual behaviour, and ensure that access to data is tightly controlled.
These strategies can help businesses secure themselves against internal risks, hence ensuring that their most valued assets, such as people and data, remain safe.
As security expert Bruce Schneier once said, “The problem isn’t technology; it’s people.” Although technology can assist in some way, an alert staff that has relevant knowledge and is security-minded will be the ultimate solution to insider threats.
You can reach out to me via email or connect with me on LinkedIn.
